Netflix's New Offering: 'Uglies'
Netflix has recently added another film to its ever-expanding library, catering especially to fans of young adult (YA) fiction. 'Uglies,' directed by McG, transports viewers into a dystopian future where societal norms are governed by strict beauty standards. The movie is based on Scott Westerfeld’s popular YA novel of the same name and features Joey King in the lead role of Tally Youngblood. As is common in dystopian tales, the narrative explores the tension between individuality and societal conformity, but critics argue that it feels like a retread of familiar ground from other similar adaptations.
The Plot and Its Themes
'Uglies' sets itself in a world where every teenager is mandated to undergo cosmetic surgery to become 'pretty.' The protagonist, Tally Youngblood, is on the brink of this transformation when her friend Shay, played by Brianne Tju, decides to run away instead of conforming to the society’s beauty standards. Tally is then coerced by the authorities to track down her friend or face her own exile. This ordeal forces Tally to confront deeply ingrained societal values and question her own beliefs about worth and beauty.
The movie’s exploration of beauty, self-worth, and societal pressures is striking, but critics argue that its treatment of these themes often feels superficial. While such heavy topics are brought up, they are not delved into with the depth and gravity they require. Instead, they say, the film approaches them in a somewhat light-hearted manner that diminishes their impact, leaving the viewer longing for a more profound exploration.
An Ensemble Cast Led by Joey King
Joey King, who gained fame from her roles in 'The Kissing Booth' series, portrays Tally Youngblood and delivers a performance that is both earnest and engaging. However, critics have noted that King’s version of Tally sometimes feels too reminiscent of her past characters, which could distract from her ability to fully embody Tally’s complex emotions and motivations. Brianne Tju, playing Shay, adds a rebellious yet vulnerable layer to the narrative, making her character's decision to flee more understandable and emotionally resonant.
The supporting cast deliver competent performances, but none stand out as particularly memorable. This has led some to feel that the film falls short in giving its characters the depth they deserve, leading to a somewhat flat emotional palette throughout the movie.
Comparison with Other YA Adaptations
No discussion of 'Uglies' can be complete without comparing it to previous YA dystopian movies like 'The Maze Runner,' 'Divergent,' and 'The Hunger Games.' These films set a high benchmark with their innovative takes on future societies and complex character arcs. Unfortunately, 'Uglies' seems to struggle to differentiate itself within this crowded genre. Despite its unique premise centered around enforced beauty standards, it remains structured too similarly to its predecessors, making it difficult to stand out among the crowd.
Both William Bibbiani from TheWrap and Nick Schager from The Daily Beast have referred to it as another formulaic entry in the genre. They highlight that while the film can be entertaining, it lacks the originality and depth needed to make a lasting impact. Bibbiani went as far as describing it as 'something to fill a quota' rather than an earnest effort to tell a compelling story.
The Entertainment Value
Despite the criticism, there's no denying the entertainment value 'Uglies' offers, particularly for its target demographic—teenagers and fans of YA fiction. The film's setting is visually appealing, with a blend of futuristic and dystopian elements that keep the viewer engaged. Brian Orndorf from Blu-ray comments that while the action and exposition are 'palatable,' they ultimately do not elevate the film to a noteworthy status within the genre.
From daring escape sequences to moments of introspective confrontation, the film provides an adrenaline rush paired with thoughtful moments. However, these moments are fleeting and often not explored to their full potential, leaving viewers wanting more substance.
Final Verdict
Whether or not 'Uglies' will find a lasting place in the hearts of its audiences remains to be seen. As of now, it bears the hallmark of a watchable YA adaptation that doesn't necessarily break new ground. While Joey King's performance has its moments of brilliance, they are often overshadowed by the film's inability to transcend the familiar tropes of the genre. For those new to YA dystopian narratives, this film could provide engaging entertainment, but for seasoned fans, it may feel like a familiar path walked many times before.
Given that 'Uglies' does not yet have a Rotten Tomatoes score, it will be interesting to see how general audiences and other critics respond after its wider release. The fact remains, though: in a world where beauty standards are highly scrutinized, this film had the potential to make a significant statement but only seems to lightly touch the surface.
Write a comment